By Dave Dougherty and Brad Strand
(November 20, 2026)
In 2024, Daniel Aronson wrote a book titled The Value of Values: How Leaders Can Grow Their Businesses and Enhance Their Careers by Doing the Right Thing. The thesis of this book is that acting on values, that is, doing good for the benefit of all, can substantially benefit a company’s bottom line. Further, acting on values increases a company’s power, profit, and competitive advantage with little additional investment or risk. Borrowing from that title, we explore the ‘value of positive values’ in high school sports and how having the positive values can benefit a team.

Young athletes’ decisions to participate in sports almost always begin with a goal of having fun. They love catching and hitting a baseball; dribbling, passing, and shooting a basketball; securing a takedown or fall in wrestling; and spiking, digging, or setting in volleyball. Athletes have fun when they have success performing skills found in any sport. The recipe for “fun” in sports is very simple in the beginning.
As athletes age, their coaches, parents, teammates, schools, and communities place expectations on them that create environments that force athletes to accept the goals of other people if they want to continue their participation. These goals may be personal or parental goals such as: the need to make the varsity, the need to be on the starting unit, the need to receive the proper amount of playing time. Failing in these goals often strain family dynamics which then reduces the “fun” an athlete wants from sports. Goals may also be coaches’ and teammates’ goals including: the need to win contests; winning end-of-season competitions; putting personal needs secondary to team needs which may include, putting practice before family and friends, the use of steroids to gain an advantage, or falsifying an age or weight in order to participate at a lower level. These are just a few examples taken from an abundance of examples available. Athletes certainly set some of these priorities but many come from others who are invested in the athlete’s participation. This then creates a conundrum of what is to be gained from participation in youth sports. Is the outcome to have ‘fun’ or is it to ‘win at all cost’ and what values are to be encouraged, ‘play fairly’ or ‘do whatever it takes to win’?

Values can be defined as personal or organizational beliefs and one’s internal motivators about what is important. They are the core principles that drive us, guide our decisions, shape our attitudes, and serve as a moral compass. Values are subjective, and vary from one person to the next and can be broadly categorized as personal, social, moral/ethical, spiritual, cultural, economic, and aesthetic with examples such as compassion, integrity, and equality. But it is difficult to talk about values without understanding ethics.
Ethics are the structured rules and standards that govern our actions. They are the external standards that guide our daily choices. Ethics are more consistent than values and are uniformly applied across groups. Examples include positive ethics include honesty, fairness, respect, and responsibility. In summary, values define your priorities and what you want to achieve while ethics decide what is right and wrong in specific situations. One’s ethics are displayed through ones’ values and are often referred to as principles, standards, or beliefs.

Sport team without a sense of principles are often reckless, out of control, irresponsible, and difficult to coach. Standards provide clarity in how a team and its players will function and behave. Without established beliefs, behavior is hard to control as there are no structural principles on which to fall back on. One misbehavior is treated one way while a similar misbehavior is treated completely differently, causing confusion and ambiguity among teammates. In a practical sense, a star athlete comes late to practice and nothing is said while a bench warmer comes late and is made to run for being late. While both athletes come late to practice the discipline is different, causing confusion as to why one has to run and the other doesn’t. This is not to say that every athlete should be disciplined in the same way. Every situation has a back story and sometimes those backstories warrant different discipline. The point we are making is that for similar actions there should be similar discipline, regardless of athlete status on the team.
The remainder of this article shows how positive values set standards, build a positive culture, define identity, shape character, guide behavior, drive decision-making, and foster relationship. It should be understood that we are referring to positive values such as honesty, fairness, and cooperation when we talk about values throughout these examples. We certainly understand that values with a negative connotation such as dishonesty, selfishness, and cheating can also set the culture and drive decision-making.

Values Help Set Standards
Although coaches have the final say on what values a team will choose, it is certainly important to involve athletes in the determination of those values. Basketball coach Mike Krzyzewski coached the 2008 Redeem Team in the Olympic Games and lead that team with a values-based culture that became known as the ‘Gold Standards’ (Hoffman, 2015). Krzyzewski let the players set the shared standards and core values for the team. Some of those values included, Communication (players and staff were expected to look each other in the eye, speak openly, and always tell the truth), Trust (everyone on the roster and staff was responsible for having each other’s back on and off the court), and Collective Responsibility (the team celebrated wins together and avoided finger-pointing or blaming individuals during losses).
Values Build a Positive Culture
In similar fashion, the New Zealand All Blacks rugby culture is built on a set of core values (Kerr, 2013). Some of the All Blacks values include, Sweep the Sheds (senior and star players physically clean and sweep out the changing room after every match, reinforcing that no individual is above the team or basic responsibilities), No Dickheads (strict cultural filter that prioritizes attitude, unity, and team synergy over toxic egos or isolated talent), and Leave the Jersey in a Better Place (players view themselves as temporary custodians of an unbroken historical chain, responsible for passing a stronger legacy to future generations).

Values Define Identity
The values one follows directly influences one’s attitudes and behaviors and helps set guardrails. Mike Methany was a professional baseball player for 13 seasons and later became a major league manager with the Cardinals. During his time between retirement from playing and becoming a manger, he coached little league baseball. It was during this time that he wrote what became known as the Matheny Manifesto (Matheny & Jenkins, 2015). This book began as a five-page letter to the parents of his little league team with his expectations. Later in the book Matheny used stories and examples to talk about eight core principles or values of sports and life (leadership, confidence, teamwork, faith, class, character, toughness, humility). The original five-page letter set the identity of his team and expectations for how parents were to behave before, during, and after games and practices.
Values Shape Character
Values shape cultural architects, those formal and informal leaders who actively model and reinforce the group’s desired behavioral norms. In one of the most notable moments in sports history, Kenyan runner Abel Matai was just a few feet from the finish line, but became confused with the signage and stopped, thinking he had completed the race. A Spanish athlete, Ivan Fernandez, was right behind him, and after realizing what was happening, he started shouting at the Kenyan for him to continue running; but Mutai didn’t understand his Spanish. Fernandez eventually caught up to him and instead of passing him, he pushed him to victory. A journalist asked Ivan, “Why did you do that?” Ivan replied, “My dream is that someday we can have a kind of community life where we push and help each other to win,” The journalist insisted, “But why did you let the Kenyan win?” Ivan replied, “I didn’t let him win, he was going to win.” The journalist insisted again, “But you could have won!” Ivan looked at him and replied, “But what would be the merit of my victory? What would be the honor of that medal? What would my mom think of me?” (EWTN News, 2013)

Values Guide Behavior
The Vanderbilt Commodores baseball team has become one of the best in recent history. Head coach Tim Corbin has over 900 wins with the Commodores and has coached his teams to two national titles along with two runner-up finishes. As part of the culture Corbin has built at Vanderbilt, his players have adopted the ‘Vandy Boys’ identity that fosters a team-first mentality in which players compete for one another rather than individual stats.
Corbin has established standards over rules and his program operates on high behavioral standards and core values, for example, “don’t embarrass your parents”. Corbin says that “rules are for people who can’t follow direction, standards are for people who aspire to special things.” Another example is to practice the ‘good neighbor policy’ in which players are expected to respect local neighborhood quiet hours, property upkeep, and community laws.
Values Drive Decision-Making
Values are the invisible force that acts as a moral compass when making decisions. The values that have been established help evaluate options, prioritize goals, and navigate ethical dilemmas. When one’s choices are congruent with one’s values, one experiences a sense of integrity and alignment. An example of this might be when a coach decides not to play a star player who has violated a team rule or academic code just before an important game. By benching the player, the coach has prioritized accountability, fairness, and integrity over winning.

Fort Wayne basketball coach John Coffman says, “Core values should not be used as strict guidelines, but rather an operating framework that individuals within your organization can reference in any circumstance they face. If your employees, players or followers perceive your values to be rules, then they will either find ways to subvert them, or live in fear of breaking them. Your goal should always be to teach the members of your organization how to think for themselves while concurrently having a basis to make the right decision every time” (Belzer, n.d.).
Values Foster Relationships
The values a team adheres to play a crucial role in the relationships that are fostered. Shared values form the foundation of strong connections and the fostering of trust, understanding, and mutual respect. On the flip side, conflicting values can strain relationships and lead to misunderstandings or disagreements. In all of the examples presented previously, the practiced positive values fostered stronger team cohesion and healthier personal relationships. The players cared more about the team than themselves, they stuck up for one another when things went bad, and they aired their grievances in a constructive manner. A great leader will help his or her team identify their team values and create clarity around those values.
Summary
What people buy into is what they want to be. One can see what people value by how they act, what they do, and how they talk. One of the most valuable tools coaches have for shaping young athletes is through positive values. Values have tremendous value, but only if they are lived. Talking about positive values is not enough, coaches must model and reinforce the values through their behavior, their decision-making, and through the culture they establish. Authentic leadership results when personal integrity aligns with organizational goals, ensuring leaders model the exact behaviors they demand from others. The values then become “Who we are”, “What we do”, and “How we act.”
References
Aronson, D. (2024). The value of values: How leaders can grow their businesses and enhance their careers by doing the right thing. Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Belzer, J. (nd). Building a value-driven culture in college athletics. ADU. https://athleticdirectoru.com/articles/building-a-value-driven-culture-in-college-athletics/
EWTN News. (2013, Jan 11). Spanish athlete sets example of kindness, sportsmanship. EWRN News. https://www.ewtnnews.com/world/europe/spanish-athlete-sets-example-of-kindness-sportsmanship
Hoffman, K. (2015, Nov 27). Revisiting Mike Kryzewski’s ‘Gold Standards’. Coach & A.D. https://coachad.com/news/revisiting-mike-krzyzewskis-gold-standards/
Kerr, J. (2013). Legacy: What the all blacks can teach us about the business of life. Litte, Brown Book Group.
Matheny, M. & Jenkins, J. (2015). The Matheny manifesto: A young manager’s old school views on success in sports and life. Crown Publishing Group.
Editor’s Note: All articles in Sport Coach America are authentic and original work by the author(s).





